-
Shawn Lee Martin, Director
-
Chris Hulsey, Producer
-
Ashton Hulsey, Producer
-
Vonessa Martin, Producer
About the Project
In 1989, Jimmie Wade Martin Jr. was killed in Bonne Terre, Missouri, a working-class town in the Missouri Ozarks. He was 29. His twin daughters, Andrea and Angela, were 11.
A man was arrested and charged and spent three years in prison. Three days before trial, the prosecuting attorney dropped the charges. The case went cold, and a small town learned to live around the silence. For Jimmie’s daughters, there was no moving on.
When the twins turned 29, the same age their father was when he was killed, their own children began asking about their carried grief. So the twins started asking again. They were told nothing more could be done. They refused to accept that. They dug into records, tracked down witnesses, and kept pushing for the truth.
In November 2020, their cousins, Shawn Lee Martin and his wife Vonessa, and Chris Hulsey and his wife Ashton, launched Small Town Forgotten to bring attention to the twins’ fight. The DIY family podcast reached more than 325,000 downloads in 90 countries without paid promotion, focusing on the family and the town rather than the crime. What started as a way to tell the twins’ story became part of it.
In August 2024, 35 years after Jimmie’s death, a different man was arrested and charged in connection with the case.
Made in association with Vagrant Media Productions, the documentary follows the family, the town, and the twins’ challenges on the long road to a courtroom. Over six years, the podcast and film teams have been welcomed into homes, churches, and a community that has carried this story for decades. As a new prosecution brings the past into the present, the film explores why rural families can wait decades for answers, how a community carries the weight of silence, and what we owe the survivors.